15 Best Restaurants & Places in Lewiston – 2024 (Top Eats!)
Lewiston is a busy metropolis in Niagara County in New York and is known for its diverse population of different tribes and ethnicities.
It is very close to the Canadian border and is a center point that attracts a lot of travelers and tourists from all over the world.
People love visiting Lewiston as the place is a perfect example of universality, hospitality, and calmness.
With such diversity, Lewiston also has an impeccable culinary reputation for serving fantastic cuisine through some of the classiest restaurants.
It would be a shame to visit Lewiston and not take a look at some of its places to eat, as the dining establishments here are excellent.
Therefore let’s take a look below at some of the best restaurants in Lewiston that you can visit.
The Best Restaurants in Lewiston This Year
1. Village Bake Shoppe
Why it’s a must visit?
The Village Bake Shoppe was started in 1993 and was opened by a family who started their own food business, which is now one of the top restaurants in Lewiston.
This restaurant is very close to the Niagara Falls River and has tons of tourists coming in who enjoy the enchanting atmosphere of this restaurant.
The restaurant provides a warm meal and has delivered consistent quality for 29 years and is also perfect for birthdays, weddings, and other special occasions.
Chef’s choice
It’s one of the best family restaurants to enjoy different variety of dishes with comfort.
It is mainly known for its toothsome varieties like sandwiches, strawberry shortcakes, ricotta, quiche, bacon, and cakes.
The drink menu is also spectacular, with beverages like lattes, espresso, juices, and smoothies.
Location and Contact
- 417 Center St, Lewiston, NY 14092-1603
- Website
- Phone:- +1 716-754-2300
- Email:- info@villagebakeshoppe.com
2. Brickyard Pub & BBQ
Why it’s a must visit?
The Brickyard Pub & BBQ restaurant is a hidden gem in Lewiston, NY, that offers mouthwatering meals at affordable options with a friendly atmosphere.
It’s an excellent restaurant that will not burn a hole in your pocket with its remarkable wood-fired made dishes that tantalizes taste buds.
The restaurant delivers excitement and fun with a bustling atmosphere and other features like giving takeout and having full bar access.
Chef’s choice
Enjoy their excellent menu selections like a quesadilla, tenderloin steak salad, black bean and corn mix, and brisket salad.
Other carnivore selections include Brickyard, chicken brisket, jalapeño poppers, fried pickle chips, and pizza logs.
As they also have a bar, one can also order drinks to complement the dishes.
Location and Contact
- 432 Center St, Lewiston, NY 14092-1604
- Website
- Phone:- +1 716-754-7227
- Email:- brickyardpub@gmail.com
3. Orange Cat Coffee Co
Why it’s a must visit?
The Orange Cat Coffee Co is an American Kathy designed in an old school-like fashion in the suburbs of Lewiston.
It’s one of the most incredible restaurants near me that is highly prized for its traditional feel and marvelous selections of delicious options.
Its cozy ambiance makes one feel at home while also enjoying the calming atmosphere with Western drink options.
Chef’s choice
The restaurant is known for offering one of the most impeccable Western food varieties, including morning delights like coffee or tasty chocolate drink.
It also has many nutritious breakfast options that feel like a sort of ritual because of so much impressive variety.
Some drink highlights for breakfast here include cappuccino, café mocha, espresso, redeye, smoothies, hot cocoa, Italian soda, white milk, and chocolate milk.
As for the meals, some light options include Café sandwiches, daily soup, nutty pear salad, wraps, and falafel salad.
Location and Contact
- 703 Center St, Lewiston, NY 14092-1705
- Phone:- +1 716-754-2888
4. Apple Granny
Why it’s a must visit?
The Apple Granny restaurant is one of the most famous restaurants in Lewiston, known for its delectable apple pie all over in New York.
The restaurant serves delectable food near my options and has been consistent in providing quality meals to its customers.
Whenever one wonders where to eat at a reputed Lewiston restaurant, this one is the top favorite.
It has strived so much to successfully use its generational recipes that people keep coming back here repeatedly.
Chef’s choice
This restaurant leaves a mark on everybody’s heart with its delicious Italian favorites like lasagna pasta and linguine pasta.
It also has impressive seafood options like fried scallops, baked haddock, salmon, and boiled shrimp.
Whereas in the white meat section, they have the tastiest boneless chicken breast, sandwiches, chicken Parmesan, petite filet mignon, and fillet of sirloin.
Location and Contact
- 433 Center St, Lewiston, NY 14092-1603
- Website
- Phone:- +1 716-754-2028
- Email:- applegrannyburke@gmail.com
5. Dicamillo Bakery
Why it’s a must visit?
The Dicamillo Bakery is known for its motto of providing a “luxury assortment of biscotti” in Lewiston.
It’s a fancy restaurant that provides gourmet meals with its bakery-like atmosphere and wholesome baked goodies.
This restaurant provides the sweetest baked goodies in Lewiston and is one of the top favorites.
Since its opening in 1920 by the Di Camillo family, it has become one of the main spots to try freshly baked goods.
Chef’s choice
The restaurant serves the tastiest Italian baked delicacies like breadsticks and Italian Scaletta bread, as it’s some fabulous options.
Other comfort varieties include peanut stick donuts, Tarallini, pasta, and sauces.
Location and Contact
- 535 Center St, Lewiston, NY 14092-1607
- Website
- Phone:- +1 716-754-2218
- Email:- info@dicamillobakery.com
6. Carmelo’s Coat of Arms
Why it’s a must visit?
Another top restaurant in Lewiston is Carmelo’s Coat of Arms Diner, which is an excellent choice for those who love indigenous Italian cuisine by also engaging with Italian culture.
It’s a perfect place to mingle with actual Italian people as well as Lewiston locals and form good connections.
Besides being one of the cool places to eat Italian cuisine in Lewiston, this one also keeps the Italian vision alive by using generational recipes dating back to 1980.
It carries the Legacy of its founder by producing the most popular meals in Lewiston and providing fulfilling options.
Chef’s choice
The restaurant promotes its native Italian culture by producing the most authentic Italian cuisine with several non-vegetarian and vegetarian options.
It masterfully creates those Italian dishes in its kitchen by following old recipes and also delivering Staples in Lewiston.
Some impressive varieties here include Octopus À La Plancha, Chilled Sweet Corn Bisque, and Crostini.
Others on the lighter side include Blistered Green Beans, Meatballs, Carmelo Salad, Calamari Salad, Burrata, Rigatoni, and Spaghetti.
On the non-veg side, some of the best ones are Filet Mignon, Squid Ink Linguini, Faroe, Lumache, Diavolo, and Islands Salmon.
Location and Contact
- 425 Center St, Lewiston, NY 14092-1603
- Website
- Phone:- +1 716-754-2311
- Email:- carmeloslewiston@gmail.com
7. Casa Antica
Why it’s a must visit?
The Casa Antica restaurant, as the name indicates, is an Italian restaurant that literally means an old house in English.
It’s an incredible restaurant that serves homey food choices seasoned by chefs and is ready to spoil its customers with some of the best flavors.
The restaurant has several notable features, including takeout service, outdoor seating, serving alcohol, and providing reservations.
Chef’s choice
The restaurant features several incredible Italian delights like Gnocchi Pasta Al Pesto, Homemade Rigatoni Pasta, Fettuccine Bolognese, and Homemade Potato Gnocchi.
In the seafood section, they have some of the most delectable choices like Linguine Alle Vongole Seafood & Pasta, Veraci, Risotto Capesante Zuppa Di Pesce Marinara, and Linguine With Clams.
Other items on the menu are also worth looking at, as all of them are delicious.
Location and Contact
- 490 Center St, Lewiston, NY 14092-1606
- Website
- Phone:- +1 716-754-2581
8. The Spicey Pickle
Why it’s a must visit?
The Spicey Pickle is one of the great restaurants when it comes to Mexican cuisine that was opened in 2014 in Lewiston, New York.
It is one of the most famous restaurants for Mexican cuisine in the city. That was first opened by Aaron Rotella and since then continued to deliver excellent dishes.
Despite being one of the most sought places for Mexican cuisine in New York, it’s also unique as there are several southwestern options too.
The restaurant includes several distinct features, like having cozy seating and a takeout service for easy accessibility.
Chef’s choice
Having a misspelled term is not only the unique part about this restaurant but also its incredible southwestern options that come in a lot of variety.
Some of the most excellent options here, which are authentic Mexican food, include Chips & Cheese, Tacos, Salsa, Jalapeños, Loaded Nachos, Guacamole, Spicey Pickles, and Chips & Salsa.
Other honorable options on the lighter side include Mixed Lettuce, Pedro’s Spinach Salad, and Roasted Chicken With Vegetables.
Location and Contact
- 463 Center St, Lewiston, NY 14092-1605
- Website
- Phone:- +1 716-754-2044
- Email:- thespiceypickle@yahoo.com
9. Syros Restaurant
Why it’s a must visit?
The Syros restaurant is another remarkable American restaurant that provides both American and Greek cuisine with several flavorsome options.
The restaurant provides a fine dining experience at an affordable rate and is clearly a local favorite because of so many diverse options.
It’s a pretty rare restaurant as it delivers authentic cuisine in exotic forms.
Chef’s choice
The restaurant is praised all over New York for its excellent and authentic Greek menu with well-prepared and nutritious dishes.
People love trying out their Hot Chocolate, Coffee, and other beverages as morning options.
Other authentic Greek varieties include Salad, Caesar Salad, Hamburger, Souvlaki Wrap, and Cheeseburger.
On the heavier side, they also have some fantastic options like Moussaka Spanakopita Dinner, Ham Melt, Steak Sandwich, Shrimp Wrap, Fish Sandwich, Souvlaki Platter, or Roasted Beef Dinner.
Location and Contact
- 869 Cayuga St, Lewiston, NY 14092-1735
- Website
- Phone:- +1 716-754-1900
- Email:- cobtielias@gmail.com
10. Favorite’s Pizzeria
Why it’s a must visit?
The Favorite’s Pizzeria restaurant is a favorite place of kids and is one of the best family restaurants in Lewiston, New York, that serves delectable pizzas.
It’s an excellent restaurant that is perfect for people who are just looking for some delicious fast food and quick bites and are in a rush.
This restaurant has a really fast service and saves both time and money by delivering your food as early as possible with affordable rates.
It is also highly comfortable and accommodates large groups of people while also featuring takeout services.
The pocket-friendly family prices here, as well as the heartwarming atmosphere, makes dining here feel worth it.
Chef’s choice
The restaurant features various classic pizza options like Deep Dish Pan, New York Pie, Pan Pizza, Calzone Pizza, Old Fashioned Pizza, and Stromboli Pizza.
Some simple ones include Broccoli & Cheddar Pizza, Margarita Pizza, Spinach Ricotta Pizza, and tomato Ricotta Pizza.
Some that we would recommend are Spinach & Artichoke Pizza, Tomato Basil Pizza, and Greek Lovers Pizza.
Location and Contact
- 781 Cayuga St, Lewiston, NY 14092-1745
- Website
- Phone:- +1 716-754-8880
- Email:- favoritespizza@mail.com
11. Villa Coffee House
Why it’s a must visit?
The Villa Coffee House restaurant is an original American cage situated in Lewiston, NY, that offers excellent brunch choices.
The several beverages here render people refreshed and satisfied, ready for an excellent morning.
The restaurant began during the 1970s and has delivered peak performance by offering some of the nicest morning delights in Lewiston.
It has everything to keep you rejuvenated and energized for the incoming day to ensure that you come back here again to begin your morning.
Chef’s choice
Because of so many excellent breakfast varieties, early risers love this restaurant and are its loyal patrons.
The restaurant offers delicious cups of drinks like espresso, coffee, and cappuccino as refreshing beverage options.
The main rejuvenating variety here includes toast, sandwiches, French toast, simple omelets, western omelets, and pancakes.
Location and Contact
- 769 Cayuga St, Lewiston, NY 14092-1723
- Website
- Phone:- +1 716-754-2660
- Email:- twoonetwokitchen@gmail.com
12. Cask and Cow
Why it’s a must visit?
The Cask and Cow restaurant is a unique dining establishment that is spearheaded by two owners who are incredibly passionate about hospitality and creating impressive cuisine.
It’s an iconic restaurant and will remain one for several years to come ever since its opening in 2017 to give people a good time.
The restaurant delivers a promising performance by prioritizing its fine dining experience in creating the most delicate cuisine variety ever!
Chef’s choice
The restaurant is highly rated for its quality cuisine and freshly made delicious cuisine that has a sweet taste.
Even though it was recently opened, it quickly became a hit dining establishment that is perfect for elegant diner lovers to visit.
Some delicious carnivore options include Pork Belly Tacos, Prime Rib Burger, Chicken Tacos, Barbacoa Shrimp Basket, Beef Taco, and Chicken Wings.
Other menu highlights are Spicy Battered Curds, Texas Fries, and buffalo Battered Cauliflower, which can also be enjoyed as side dishes.
Location and Contact
- 840 Center St, Lewiston, NY 14092-1739
- Website
- Phone:- +1 716-405-7063
- Email:- caskandcow@gmail.com
13. Hibbard’s Custard
Why it’s a must visit?
The Hibbard’s Custard restaurant is a famous dessert place in Lewiston that people with sweet tooth love to visit.
It has been running since the year 1939 and is considered to be one of the oldest and nicest breakfast restaurants in the US.
It’s also one of the most famous restaurants in Lewiston because of its unique recipes that are constantly getting better and becoming much tastier.
Chefs choice
This restaurant is known for providing the most wholesome variety of delicious and tasty dishes, including desserts that have received a 5-star rating.
With its incredible reputation, the restaurant has received tons of appreciation for its various menu specialties that come in different flavors.
When it comes to their dessert menu, they have the nicest custard and ice cream varieties that come in different options like hot fudge, butterscotch, and Sundays, and add a variety of different flavors.
Location and Contact
- 105 Portage Rd, Lewiston, NY 14092-1709
- Website
- Phone:- +1 716-754-4218
- Email:- hfhibbard@gmail.com
14. Silo Restaurant
Why it’s a must visit?
The Silo restaurant is a perfect American restaurant when one is speculating where to eat quick-bite options in Lewiston.
It is reputed to be one of the top-rated restaurants in Lewiston that offers both outdoor and indoor dining experiences with tasty meal options.
It was started during the 1990s and quickly became famous for its excellent customer service and unique flavored dishes that are also available at cheap rates.
Since its opening, it’s been around for so long and has become a highlight for its impressive ambiance with a waterfront setting, high chairs, indoor and outdoor seating, public gift cards, and various other accessible facilities.
Chef’s choice
This restaurant carves its own value with readily available and delicious options.
There are several incredible different types of hotdogs like Zweigle’s White Hot, Silo Footlong Hot Dog, and Premium Black Angus Beef Hot Dog.
Other favorites which are also worth a try include Silo Supreme Footlong, Silo Monster Dawg, Silo Supreme Dog, Cheese Dog, Chili Dog, Silo Dixie Dog, and Footlong Chili Dog.
Location and Contact
- 115 N Water St, Lewiston, NY 14092-1283
- Website
- Phone:- +1 716-754-9680
- Email:- info@lewistonsilo.com
15. Tin Pan Alley
Why it’s a must visit?
The Tin Pan Alley restaurant has been operating for 25 years and serves an exclusive American menu with complete dedication and passion.
It’s a perfect restaurant for tourists and residents to visit as it serves an excellent southwestern meal in a heartwarming way.
It is also considered a village restaurant and a pub where lots of local people gather to enjoy a variety of delicious meals with nicely brewed beer.
This restaurant is a great place to enjoy the company of others and have more fun than the actual food because of the gracious hospitality of southwestern people.
By welcoming people from all over the world, this restaurant feels like a suitable safe space to connect and have tasty meals.
Chef’s choice
Our personal recommendation would go here for their Mushroom Swiss Burger, The Big Texan, and Plain Hamburger.
Other delicious delights include California Dreaming, Cheeseburger, Tripple Chocolate Cake, Shrimp Grilled Chicken, and Mediterranean.
Their sandwiches, like Bacon, Bacon Lettuce, and Tomatoes sandwiches, are also good.
Location and Contact
- 775 Cayuga St, Lewiston, NY 14092-1720
- Website
- Phone:- +1 716-754-4330
- Email:- webmaster@tinpanalley716.com
Final Thoughts
Lewiston is a charming restaurant filled with excellent places to eat that you can dine in comfortably without any hassle.
With so many exceptional restaurants available in every corner, you do not feel incomplete in trying so many delicious servings from various different countries.
The diverse selections of cuisine here, ranging from Greek, and Italian to Mexican, makes Lewiston a culturally diverse place with both heartwarming people and places.
It’s a beautiful experience exploring the city and visiting various iconic landmarks while enjoying the sweetness of the meals and the rich history of Lewiston.
Despite all that, it is crucial to narrow down your favorite dining establishments. Because of this, we created this list of the best restaurants in Lewiston.
We hope that this article will help you in deciding the right choice according to your preference.
