Restaurants in Long Island for Thanksgiving dinner

13 Best Restaurants Open for Thanksgiving Dinner Long Island – 2024

ByKashish Jamal Hashmi

Ah, Thanksgiving—a time of gratitude, family, and let’s not forget, mouthwatering food! But what if you’re not up for the kitchen marathon this year?

Or perhaps you’re new to Long Island and are looking for a local hotspot to savor a sumptuous Thanksgiving feast?

Well, you’re in luck! Long Island isn’t just a summertime paradise; it transforms into a haven of culinary delights just in time for Turkey Day.

From cozy, family-run inns to upscale waterfront venues, we’ve rounded up a list of the best places for a memorable Thanksgiving dinner.

So loosen up those belt buckles and prepare for a gastronomic journey that you’ll be grateful for!

Best restaurants in Long Island for Thanksgiving this year

1. The Milleridge Inn

The Milleridge Inn

Why it is a must-visit

Imagine stepping into a cozy place that feels like a warm hug from Grandma. That’s what it’s like at The Milleridge Inn. This place has been around for more than 80 years!

It’s a local gem with an old-school feel. The best part? It’s one of those restaurants open on Thanksgiving near me and you.

These folks know how to cook a Thanksgiving meal that’ll make you go, “Yum!” From traditional turkey to special seasonal dishes, they’ve got it all.

Need a last-minute spot for dinner? They’ve got you. They even offer takeout and dinner delivery options for a chill Thanksgiving at home. And don’t forget their pies—they’re a slice of heaven!

Location and Contact

2. Stone Creek Inn

Stone Creek Inn

Why it is a must-visit

If you’re looking for something a bit fancy but still warm and welcoming, Stone Creek Inn is where to eat.

The place is run by Chef Christian Mir and his wife Elaine, and they’ve sprinkled a little bit of magic from Southwest France right into East Quogue.

Now, let’s talk turkey—and more! This restaurant serves up some of the best Thanksgiving meals in Long Island. The food is so good you’ll want to take out your phone and snap a picture.

But wait, they also have takeout meals and even offer dinner delivery for a comfy feast at home. If you’re searching for “food near me” that’s both delicious and affordable, this is your spot.

Location and Contact

3. Ristegio’s Restaurant & Lounge

Ristegio's Restaurant & Lounge

Why it is a must-visit

Step into Ristegio’s and you’ll feel like you’ve walked into a chill, modern spot where everyone is your friend.

Located in North Patchogue, this place is a hotspot in Suffolk County. Looking for restaurants open on Thanksgiving near me? Ristegio’s is on that list!

If your taste buds are adventurers, they’ll love Ristegio’s. From steak and seafood to pasta and even sushi, they offer a mixed bag of flavors.

They serve takeout meals too, perfect for a cozy Thanksgiving dinner at home. Plus, they often have live entertainment. It’s a local favorite for affordable, diverse food choices.

Location and Contact

4. HK Bar & Restaurant

HK Bar & Restaurant

Why it is a must-visit

Fancy dining like royalty? HK Bar & Restaurant offers you that experience, right in the heart of OHEKA CASTLE.

Yep, a real castle on Long Island’s Gold Coast! When you’re wondering where to eat something special, this place should top your list.

If you’re all about European-style dining, you’ll love it here. Perfect for a best-in-class Thanksgiving Dinner in Long Island, you’ll find each dish here is a work of art.

From the starters to the main courses, everything feels lavish yet close to home. They offer dinner delivery as well, just in case you prefer your castle to be your living room.

Location and Contact

5. Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering

Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering

Why it is a must-visit

How about dining with a view? Captain Bill’s offers just that, with a spectacular look at the Bay Shore Marina.

This South Shore gem is the ultimate waterfront restaurant. It’s an awesome place for people searching for ‘food near me’ with a stunning backdrop.

Taste the sea with their exquisite seafood options or go classic with a turkey dinner. Either way, you’re in for a treat.

They offer takeout too for those looking to bring the feast back home. From the food to the service, everything about Captain Bill’s makes it a perfect place for a Thanksgiving meal.

Location and Contact

6. Peppercorns Restaurant & Catering

Peppercorns Restaurant & Catering

Why it is a must-visit

When you step into Peppercorns in Hicksville, you’re not just stepping into a restaurant; you’re joining a family meal!

It’s super cozy and just the right spot for a feel-good experience. If you’re looking for restaurants open on Thanksgiving ‘near me,’ this one should be on your radar.

Peppercorns know how to do food right. From mouth-watering appetizers to hearty main courses, you’ll leave with a happy tummy.

They offer more than just a dine-in option; they also have catering and takeout. So if you fancy a meal at home, they’ve got you covered with dinner delivery!

Location and Contact

7. Mill Pond House

Mill Pond House

Why it is a must-visit

If you’re a fan of views and history, Mill Pond House is your spot. It’s almost a century old and overlooks the Mill Pond of Centerport.

The place is open all year, so it’s not just a summertime deal. Thinking about where to eat for a memorable Thanksgiving Dinner in Long Island? Add this to your list.

The food here is as breathtaking as the views. They’ve got a range of options, including sushi, steaks, and the freshest local seafood.

They also offer catering for those who’d prefer to feast at home. Their extensive wine list even won an award! This place is all about quality.

Location and Contact

8. Mim’s Restaurant

Mim's Restaurant

Why it is a must-visit

Mim’s is the neighbor you always wish you had but in restaurant form. Known for its warm hospitality, this place is where casual meets elegant. It’s one of the local favorites for good reason.

The food here is a celebration of American cuisine, packed with flavors that pop! They offer both lunch and dinner menus with daily specials that’ll make you go “wow.”

They also offer catering services, perfect for special occasions. If you’re hunting for ‘food near me’ that offers both comfort and quality, Mim’s should be your go-to.

Location and Contact

9. Mirabelle Restaurant & Tavern

Mirabelle Restaurant & Tavern

Why it is a must-visit

Imagine dining in a place that’s like a French vacation, but you’re actually in Stony Brook, Long Island. That’s Mirabelle for you.

Run by Executive Chef Guy Reuge, this spot gives you a taste of France without needing a passport. When you’re thinking about where to eat for Thanksgiving dinner, think of Mirabelle.

If you’re looking to step up your Thanksgiving dinner, Mirabelle has got you covered. Their farm-to-table tasting menu is paired with classic French bistro dishes from the Tavern.

It’s an explosion of fresh-meets-French flavors, making it a top choice for a classy Thanksgiving.

Location and Contact

10. Red Salt Room by David Burke

Red Salt Room by David Burke

Why it is a must-visit

Want to eat in a place that feels like a fairy tale? Red Salt Room by David Burke is all about relaxed elegance. With its unique Himalayan Sea Salt accents and fancy chandeliers, it’s like dining in a dream.

This is where New American cuisine gets a fresh twist. From dry-aged prime steaks to fun seasonal creations, every dish is a masterpiece.

So, if you’re looking for ‘food near me’ that’s a little bit extra, this is the spot for you. They also offer special events like Saturday Afternoon Tea and Sunday Brunch.

Location and Contact

11. Garden Grill

Garden Grill

Why it is a must-visit

Ever wanted to dine in a piece of history? Garden Grill has been around since 1873 and is a local landmark.

It’s like eating in a cozy museum, right in the heart of Long Island. Perfect for those looking for local places to eat for a special occasion.

Get ready for a comfort food bonanza. Everything here is made the old-fashioned way—slow-simmered soups, homemade stocks, and fresh seafood delivered daily.

They even offer Certified Angus Beef hand-cut in their kitchen every day. When you’re in the mood for classic American dishes, this is your go-to spot for Thanksgiving meals.

Location and Contact

12. Wantagh Inn

Wantagh Inn

Why it is a must-visit

Wantagh Inn is like that comfy old sweater you love to wear—been around for more than 30 years and is still as awesome as ever.

It’s a staple in the community and makes everyone feel like they’re part of the family. A must-visit if you’re thinking ‘where to eat’ for a good, old-fashioned Thanksgiving Dinner in Long Island.

The food here is as comforting as a hug from Grandma. Whether you’re craving fresh seafood, yummy kinds of pasta, or juicy steaks, they’ve got you covered.

Late-night snack or a full-course dinner, you’ll leave feeling more than happy. Plus, they offer takeout for those wanting a cozy meal at home.

Location and Contact

13. American Brass

American Brass

Why it is a must-visit

Imagine eating by the water, in a place that’s both relaxed and kind of fancy—that’s American Brass for you.

Located right across from the iconic Long Island City Gantries, the place has a view that’s almost as good as the food. If you’re in Long Island City and wondering about ‘food near me,’ make a beeline for American Brass.

The food here isn’t just food; it’s like a work of art on a plate. Prepared by Chef Kevin McGinley, a Michelin Star restaurant alum, every dish is crafted with love and crazy attention to detail.

What’s more, they go local in sourcing their ingredients, so you’re also supporting New York farms. It’s a full-on win-win for a special Thanksgiving meal!

Location and Contact

Conclusion

There you have it—our top picks for Thanksgiving restaurants that promise a feast worth every penny and every calorie.

From traditional American to New American cuisine, from cozy family diners to upscale spots, Long Island has something to offer for every palate and preference.

Whether you’re looking for last-minute reservations, seeking a restaurant offering takeout or dinner delivery, or wondering about free or cheap yet delectable options, our list provides an array of choices that guarantee a Happy Thanksgiving.

So go ahead, make a reservation, order in, or pick up that last-minute takeout, and may your Thanksgiving be filled with delicious food, joy, and lots and lots of love!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *